It doesn’t exist. But we keep hoping.
Welcome! You are invited to wander around and read all of the comments that have been posted here at Patton & Co., but as soon as you register you can see the bid limits that Alex, Peter and Mike propose for each player, and you can post your own comments. Registering is free, so please join us!
Feb 21 '12
Don't let that hold you back any longer.
Feb 20 '12
Feb 17 '12
Naturally, after I introduce the rule change last season, I finish last and am left trying to figure out which 7 out of 10 potential keepers to actually keep.
Feb 16 '12
The other was just stupid: Reserve picks go 5th through 12th, the 4th, 3rd, 2nd, 1st.
Feb 16 '12
Let's say you are in a 5x5 league, and you need about 90 points to win. That's fourth in each category of a 12-team league.
If you punt saves, and fall to 1 point (a bonus point for doing nothing) you need to get that 8 points somewhere else. In 5x5, it makes sense to punt saves as getting to 4th in saves is going to cost you more than $15. Where you go with the $15 depends on where the auction is going, but I think you'd spend it on players with more certainty than on speculation. Spread it where you can top two or three categories to pick up 8 points or more, which may mean starting pitching for wins and Ks or hitting to get HRs and RBI. I've seen people spend their punt money on two categories where they already were at or near the top, thus never seeing any benefit of the punt.
Feb 16 '12
The 5 keepers rule evolved up rather than down. We started with two keepers and moved to five after season 3. We've stuck with it ever since. Same with the option or extend the first year. I think that's the most effective anti-dumping rule, but it was created our first season and has never changed.
Our reserve draft order was created to keep teams interested in moving up in the standings later in the season- keep them bidding their FAAB $, etc. It may make a team in 7th more hesitant to dump b/c they will get a better prospect the next year, but that's by chance more than design.
Feb 16 '12
I am also not criticizing anyone...every league is different and every league has its own problems that need to be addressed. I am thankful that we have some pretty great owners in my two regular leagues, and we have very few issues we need to address.
Feb 16 '12
I agree with all that you are against regarding dump trades.
But doesn't have an in-season soft cap 'place limitations on how rich the rich can get'? As a matter of fact, you could argue that it also interferes with the free market.
Most people think you should do something about dumping, but most people also don't want to do those things you mentioned. Problem is, I haven't seen an anti-dumping measure that doesn't somehow infringe on the free market, or limit how rich the rich can become.
It seems to me that I have to leave my high-minded ideology behind in order to make the game of fantasy baseball work better. (Wait, no maybe I'M talking about Congress).
Feb 16 '12
The "hole" in the rule are the ultra cheap superstars. Last year Kemp was traded at a salary of 7 (last year).
Feb 16 '12