Max Scherzer New York Mets

Age: 37 (July 27, 1984) | 6' 3" | 208lbs. | Throws: Right Minors: p-33 ph-2
Tm Lg YEAR W L SV Hld G GS IP H HR BB SO ERA WHIP Rating BB/9 SO/9 BABIP G/L/F % $4x4 $5x5
WAS NL 2018 18 7 0 0 33 33 220.1 150 23 51 300 2.53 0.91 0.95 2.1 12.3 .283 34/18/48 41 40
WAS NL 2019 11 7 0 0 27 27 172.0 144 18 33 243 2.93 1.03 1.09 1.7 12.7 .342 41/21/38 27 28
WAS NL 2020 5 4 0 0 12 12 67.0 70 10 23 92 3.76 1.39 1.44 3.1 12.4 .382 33/27/40 12 18
WAS NL 2021 8 4 0 0 19 19 111.0 71 18 28 147 2.76 0.89 1.01 2.3 11.9 .242 32/17/51 21 20
LAD NL 2021 7 0 0 0 11 11 68.0 48 5 8 89 1.99 0.82 0.88 1.1 11.8 .295 35/21/44 18 16
NYM NL 2022 5 1 0 0 8 8 49.2 36 5 11 59 2.54 0.95 0.99 2.0 10.7 .277 34/19/47 11 10
Career 15yrs 195 98 0 0 415 406 2582.2 2108 292 688 3079 3.15 1.08 1.12 2.4 10.7 .302 n/a
Welcome! You are invited to wander around and read all of the comments that have been posted here at Patton & Co., but as soon as you register you can see the bid limits that Alex, Peter and Mike propose for each player, and you can post your own comments. Registering is free, so please join us!

Without league differences taken into account, deGrom was the most valuable pitcher last year in 5x5. But there is always a league difference and always will be as long as one league has the DH, and with it Scherzer edges out deGrom ($40), Verlander ($39) and Snell ($39) for the top spot. How do they compare in the various WARs?

Scherzer

Fangraphs 7.2

Baseball-Reference 8.8

Baseball Prospectus 7.7

deGrom

Fangraphs 8.8

Baseball-Reference 7.8

Baseball Prospectus 8.0

Verlander

Fangraphs 6.8

Baseball-Reference 6.2

Baseball Prospectus 7.3

Snell

Fangraphs 4.6

Baseball-Reference 5.8

Baseball Prospectus 6.0

Conclusion?

I overvalue wins.

But in fantasy baseball, guess what?

Wins count.

Alex Patton Alex
Jan 3 '19

Most valuable pitcher, both leagues, in 5x5.

2018 Statcast Averages

NP: 1746

Pitch Type: Four-seam FB

Avg Pitch Speed: 94.4

Avg Spin Rate: 2,486

Avg Exit Velocity: 86.4

Pennies better than Verlander, a dollar better than deGrom and Snell.

Alex Patton Alex
Dec 16 '18
Fangraphs: WAR 7.2    FIP 2.65    SIERA 2.71    FB 50%    FBv 94.4    HR/FB 10%    Hard 29%
Alex Patton Alex
Dec 16 '18